Picture Credit: AmericanIdol.Com
So, last week’s Top 13 show was – interesting! Lots of twists and turns and technical glitches and vocal issues.
I don’t know – I find these singers very green this season and, with Harry Connick on board, I was expecting more. Much more! Much much more!
However, at the risk of sounding like a broken record, I will state that it is early on in the season and I am sure we are in for more surprises down the road, some good, some bad – with hopefully more of the former than the latter.
I am hoping that Michael Orland, Dorian Holley and Rickey Minor – Idol’s musical triumvirate – can work some magic via their prolific music skills and expertise.
Hopefully these young singers have banished the butterflies and can maintain a stable momentum during their performances this week and beyond.
This week the theme revolves around Home. The Top 12, comprised of Ben Briley, C.J. Harris, Jena Irene, Caleb Johnson, Jessica Meuse, MK Nobilette, Emily Piriz, Alex Preston, Dexter Roberts, Majesty Rose, Malaya Watson and Sam Woolf, will perform songs that represent their home. Song selections that pay homage to their home state and/or were popular during their childhood will form the basis of their song selections.
And, Philip Philipps, the American Idol who sang his ubiquitous “Home” number to mega success, will grace the American Idol stage on the Results Show on Thursday, March 6th. It will be great to see and hear him again.
The Performance Show airs on Wednesday, March 5th at 8:00 PM Eastern on Fox.
Comments are now open for business!
Maybe it was just me, but I found tonight’s performances very boring. This is a sad, sad year for Idol. There are some who are pleasant to listen to, but not one is a spectacular talent.
LikeLike
Oh Louise – I do agree. The singers are so green, young, technically inefficient and lacking in charisma. What a mess. I was expecting more from these judges. They sent home incredible talent and for what? This? I am confused and disappointed.
LikeLike
Very underwhelming.
I still like Sam’s voice, but his performance was rather one note–and some of the others were just bad–shouty or screechy or just off.
I did appreciate the way the judges are trying to pass on their own experience to the contestants, but I don’t know if it’s sinking in at all.
LikeLike
Yes I think,the judges are in total shock and disarray over what they heard this evening. And too many singer playing guitars! Does nobody know how to stand there and sing any more? There is a sameness to all the performances.
LikeLike
I keep thinking that this year’s Idol reminds me of a high school talent show.
LikeLike
This suggestion is also a broken record. It literally does the contestant no good, especially the one that is eliminated that may have talent, for the judges to give criticism and tips after the performance. They need to find a way for their criticism and suggestions to be absorbed and presented by the contestants. I would contend that is one of the two major reasons The Voice is consistently much better. The Voice judge’s are invested in the contestant. They show the contestant how to utiiize their talent.
LikeLike
Don B.
My husband said the same thing last night! I think the criticism needs to happen on elimination night, have the judges say then what they thought of each performance! I get frustrated when they tell these kids to make the song their own, but then when they do they are like a Whack-A-Mole game! Sing in tune, don’t sing in tune, if your gonna scream make it believable?!?!?!?!?!!
My bottom three…let me pick my top three! Sam, Alex and Caleb! Based on last night if it “were” a singing contest, I would send home Pink Pony or Majesty!
LikeLike
There is much irony that we again have three young ladies in the Bottom 3. Changes need to be made. Emily really is a strong singer.
LikeLike