Here we go again. NBC’s The Voice is shaping up to be quite the shocking little show.
Who would have anticipated the live elimination of RaeLynn and Jesse Campbell by their respective coaches, Blake Shelton and Christina Aguilera last week?
They must know something I don’t know – like voting totals perhaps? It’s the only explanation I have. Maybe the marketing potential behind both singers didn’t seem feasible.
Whatever the reason, they are gone. And now, both teams are a little light on the talent, I feel. Although Jermaine Paul from Team Blake and Chris Mann from Team Christina will probably make the semi-finals.
So, it will be very interesting to see how Adam Levine and Cee Lo Green’s singers do on this Monday’s performance show.
Of the two, Cee Lo has unquestionably the strongest team and, under his creative guidance, always delivers in a memorable way.
Hopefully, Adam has selected some better songs for his singers. He did them no favors during the last round. It was a mess!
Don’t forget to leave some delicious cookie crumbs in the comments section. Or, you can join my Twitter feed..
As a fan of both Idol and The Voice, here is something I find a little odd about this year:
The Voice seeks to distinguish itself from other singing competition shows by saying that its focus is almost entirely on vocal talent (the “voice”). It proudly claims that, unlike Idol, it casts the show with only the very best vocal talent, with little regard to things like looks, personality, age, ethnicity, gay-straight, etc. that seem to be such important factors in the Idol casting process.
To implement this goal, The Voice uses a different casting system than Idol. The “cattle call” open auditions are the heart of Idol, but are only a minor factor in casting The Voice. Most of the contestants chosen for The Voice come from the “recruitment” process the show uses. It works with professional talent and casting agencies to find talent, and uses a nationwide network of recruiters who look for talent on Youtube videos and at local clubs and schools. The most promising singers found by the recruiters are then invited to audition for the show.
Here is an article that discusses the casting process on The Voice:
http://www.tvguide.com/News/Voice-Casting-NBC-1032920.aspx
What is odd is that, despite all the claims The Voice makes about being focused only on vocal talent, it seems to me that Idol this year is blowing away The Voice in vocal talent.
The Top 8 of Idol did not have a single weak vocal talent, while The Voice was littered this year with weak singers.
Logically, it would seem like the targeted recruitment process The Voice uses would produce a more talented cast than the messy, open cattle call approach that Idol uses.
But it did not seem to work this year.
Am I the only one who feels this way?
LikeLike
I agree. The only singer that I personally was excited about, Jesse Campbell, is gone. Yes, Chris Mann can sing but he doesn’t move me. So other than my mancrush on Blake, there is not much reason for me to tune in. I have the shows on TiVO so when I have an opening I will watch them. Idol is more interesting this year even if I despise the judging and how “staged” the show seems to be.
LikeLike
Malden – thanks for adding your comments. I fully agree. I have had an article in the queue for a while about The Voice VS. American Idol. I plan to add it soon as a separate blog topic.
Honestly, if you want my opinion, I think the Team Captains’ turnarounds are staged or scripted. Not all the time, but some of the time depending on the selection process of the day.
They were turning their chairs for the strangest singers – some were out of tune and just sounded plain awful. Which says to me that they purposely loaded their teams with weaker singers to balance out the strong singer ratio.
I have no proof. Just love to start controversy!! Ha!
LikeLike