Sometimes – if not all the time – you have to let the chips fall where they may. No one – not even the winner himself – could have predicted the outcome of The Voice Results Show during Tuesday’s telecast.
This season’s winner of The Voice, Jermaine Jones, poured his heart on the stage every time he performed on this show, particularly during the Top 4 Performance Show on Monday evening.
Although a couple of other strong contenders were favored to win this competition right from the earliest stages of The Voice Season 2, Jermaine humbly did his thing and continued to advance under the radar.
And, here’s the thing: very rarely were there harsh words for any competitor from any of the judges – only constructive and esteem-building criticism. In fact, many times some of the judges actually heaped on a truck load of praise for singers that were not members of their team. How’s that for fair play?
And then, we turn the dial to American Idol and watch the agenda in full swing – heaping praise on singers who give lackluster performances while damning the ones who have worked their little butts off to give stellar, consistent performances each week. Why? Where is the logic – never mind the justice – in this?
We want singers to advance fairly – not because they are the producers’ or judges’ favorites but because they are our favorites. Yes, ours! Not yours! Your job is to promote talent in the best possible way, allowing singers to display the full range of their vocal and performing ability.
Quit saddling them with songs that have no resemblance to their personal style or substance. This is not how you create stars – that’s how you destroy them. Period.
You better watch your backs, American Idol. I love you and will stick by you through thick and thin but, seriously, this game has to be played fair or you will continue to lose viewers while other shows, like The Voice, will gain momentum.
Sound-off in the comments section. I am fuming!
So very well said MCL.
You mentioned Simon being successful at getting female contestants to the victory. It was completely genius the way he sent Melanie away and then brought her back. That catapulted her right to the front as if she wasn’t already there after her audition.
I think he knew her audition was absolutely her best and she would never be able to top it so he pulled that little trick and it worked.
But to get to the point you are making in this article. All of the other judges on “The X Factor” were playing strategy with their remarks. Giving bad or less then flattering reviews to performers who didn’t deserve it while trying to get their own acts to the front.
At one point Simon said “This is war.” but he never did that. He kept giving good reviews when they were deserved and actually played fairly to my surprise.
I think Melanie winning was just as much a vote FOR Simon and AGAINST Nicole and LA as it was a vote FOR Melanie. Christina A. lost Chris Mann a lot of votes on “The Voice” also.
I personally think Melanie deserved to win “The X Factor” anyway. I was all for them just crowning her after her audition. I would have liked to see Jazzlyn Little in the mix though. I was disappointed to see her cut at Judge’s Houses. I also think that Jermaine deserved to win “The Voice”. But that is just an example of how the judges can affect the outcome negatively or positively. I don’t think Simon pulled any strings for Melanie but I do think he spent the whole season pulling all of the other judges chain….LOL.
American Idol needs to take a lesson from “The Voice” and Simon on “The X Factor” as to how to be a proper judge IMO.
LikeLike