Comments on: Vocal Masterclass Discussion Thread For American Idol Season 8: Choosing The Top 50

By: Sara

Sara — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 17:34:19 +0000

Galen and MCL, you are both absolutely right about the top 36 format. It is why I don’t like the “pimping” of some contestants over others. There are bound to be really good singers put through who haven’t had the back stories or much air time. They will have to sing like their lives depended on it to compete, and pray the judges also prop them up a bit. It isn’t a very even playing field coming into voting. Let’s hope the judges DO save some of the best who inadvertently slip through the cracks (think Clay Aiken and Jennifer Hudson)…

By: Galen

Galen — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 16:05:22 +0000

You’re very welcome, MCL! Honestly, this site of yours is the best place I have found to discuss American Idol on the web–and that includes the official website! I agree with you that I also am a bit concerned about the Top 36 format. With nine singers being sent home every week, there’s sure to be some real talent that slips through the cracks. I hope that America is very smart this year when it comes to voting. The reality is that in the normal Top 24 format, a person could probably keep his or her favorite in the competition by calling in only a few votes. Now, however, to keep your favorite alive in the competition, it is almost imperative that you vote for at least an hour for them. Get those Speed Dial buttons ready! LOL

By: masterclasslady

masterclasslady — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 15:23:44 +0000

Bizzee and Erin- I hope they bring Leneshe back. I loved her so much. Tatiana is there for filler and to ensure that the truly deserving singers get through to the Top 12. At least, that’s the plan I would think!

By: masterclasslady

masterclasslady — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 15:20:25 +0000

Sara- i agree. The singers looked and sounded thoroughly exhausted. I am sure we will see some fine singing from all of them next week, as they have had time to rest and prepare properly. Not a fan of the Top 36 format this year, so we shall see what happens.

By: masterclasslady

masterclasslady — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 15:19:10 +0000

Galen – thanks so much for your in depth comments. This takes a great deal of thought and effort on your part and I wholly appreciate your input here on the MCL site. I missed part of the episode because of some technical issues here, so your observations are much appreciated.:)

By: Galen

Galen — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 05:13:02 +0000

Well, after the fiasco that was last week’s horrendous group episode, I was so relieved that tonight’s episode got us back on track, focusing more on the singing and less on the drama! Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed tonight and look forward to the two-hour (finally) long episode tomorrow! Here are some of the highlights of tonight’s show that left an impression on me . . .

–Danny Gokey: I honestly do not know who made the Top 36 yet (I’m the minority who decided to not be spoiled) LOL! However, I have absolutely no doubt that Danny has more than secured his place within the ranks of the Top 36 and even the Top 12! His voice was excellent tonight and I LOVE the song “Dance” that he sang! He actually changed it up quite a bit and made it his own. The way he did that reminded me very much of a certain someone last season who always had a knack for making songs his own . . . and that certain someone ended becoming the American Idol! With David Osmond sadly gone, I am definitely on the verge of calling Danny my new favorite!

Scott MacIntyre: I have always had a soft spot for this guy ever since his first audition. I admire his boldness and tenacity. Being visually impaired and having the courage to take on American Idol says a lot about his strength of character. I have to be honest, when he performed Daughtry’s “Home” tonight, my exact response was a verbal “Wow! This guy can sing!” All of a sudden I became a very big fan of his and look forward to seeing him perform in the future! Now, I like both Scott and Danny! I would not be disappointed at all if either of them became the American Idol! In fact, my mom (who predicted Carrie Underwood would win after seeing her first audition) commented that she wouldn’t be surprised if it came down to Danny vs. Scott in the finals! I am certainly inclined to agree with her!

Norman Gentle–Okay. I have not been a massive fan of this guy in the past and still am not. I believe he is an excellent entertainer, but I don’t think this competition for him. However, I am not going to deny that he does have a voice underneath all of that flamboyance. I honestly am speechless. I just do not know what to make of him. Ah, well . . . I wish him the best.

–I’m really liked Ann Marie Boskovitch as well. I can’t say I’m a huge fan of hers or anything, but she left more of a positive impression on me than any of the other female singers did tonight.

–I was glad Joanna Pacitti made it through as well. She has an awesome song you can download off of iTunes, and I was thoroughly impressed by it! It is called “Let It Slide.” Has anyone else listened to it?

–Last but not least, I was just a bit disappointed that Michael Castro went home without us ever getting the chance to see him perform in Hollywood. With Jason being his brother, I admit I was curious to see how his little bro performed. Well, there’s always next season I suppose.

Like I said, tonight’s episode was brilliant and more or less I think the judges got it right. I loved how Simon left the other three judges to deliver the bad news! LOL I look so forward to tomorrow! Great masterclass, MCL, and God bless everyone on here!

By: Sara

Sara — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 04:07:33 +0000

Thank you MCL for your recap! I think most voices sounded tired and strained for the most part (though that is to be expected with the schedule, etc). I am very glad the top 36 have had a lot of time to prepare and to rest up!

By: Bizzee24

Bizzee24 — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 02:58:51 +0000

Well after a few Tuesdays of NOT being able to watch the show, I finally settled in tonight to enjoy it. Not to sure what to make of the choices by the judges….

Tatiana???? Are they for real?? She is just getting too annoying for me. To whinny ( I get her some cheese if she wants….). Too distraught. Oy.

I was very sad to see Leneshe go – she is more deserving over Tatiana (insert headshake).

Oh and Stephen Fowler…he gets through! What?!? He forgot the lyrics (…and it was the song our current A.I. to boot…) What is to say that nerves are not going to get the better of him on live T.V. (Images of Brook White flash through my head…as Ryan alluded too)

Oy – well this is my rant tonight. Hopefully tomorrow will shed some light on some of these decisions.

By: Erin

Erin — Wed, 11 Feb 2009 02:39:08 +0000

I was also disappointed that Leneshe didn’t make it. I thought she did a good job. I still can’t believe Tatiana is still in but she’s not a terrible singer, she just annoys me to death. Anyway, I am very pleased that Anoop, Adam, Jorge, Danny, Matt G., & Scott all made it through. They are all great singers.